Skip to content
Haunt & Hedge

Editorial policy

Every pick is chosen from manufacturer specifications, manuals, safety standards and verified buyer data. Here is exactly how that works.

Every pick on this site is chosen from manufacturer specifications, manuals, safety standards, current retailer listings and verified buyer data, scored against criteria published on the page itself. This page sets out that method in full, so you can see what is behind a recommendation before you buy.

1. How products are selected

Every pick on this site is chosen from four kinds of evidence:

  • Manufacturer specifications. Dimensions, wattage, materials, IP ratings, stated weather tolerance, activation modes.
  • Retailer listings. What is actually sold, in what configuration, and what is currently available.
  • Published third-party testing. Cited by name and date, credited to whoever did it. Never absorbed as ours.
  • Documented owner reports. Retailer review threads, haunt community forums and long-running discussion threads, which contain genuine ownership experience about failure modes.

Each category has its own criteria, published on the page. For inflatables it is fan type, shape geometry and anchoring. For animatronics it is street presence, build, weather tolerance, setup and storage footprint. For fog machines it is density, whether the fog stays low, run time, setup and consumable cost. You can disagree with the weighting because you can see it.

2. What the scores mean

The number on each pick is our editorial assessment of that product against the published criteria for its category, out of ten. It is a shorthand for the reasoning written next to it. Scores appear as visible page content, so you can read the rubric, the score and the reasoning together and decide whether our weighting matches your yard.

The scale is deliberately narrow, because the shortlist is already narrow. Nothing reaches a page here until it has cleared the criteria for its category, so the score is not asking is this any good — it is telling you how far past the bar a product sits:

  • 9.5 to 9.8 — category-defining. The piece we would buy first, and the one the rest of the category is measured against.
  • 9.0 to 9.4 — outstanding. Clears every criterion that matters for the way most people will use it.
  • 8.4 to 8.9 — excellent, and strongly recommended. Genuinely good, usually with one specific trade-off that decides whether it suits your yard. That trade-off is printed on the card as the “good to know” line.

There is no band below 8.4. A product that would score lower than that is not recommended on this site, so it does not get a card — it is either left off the page or replaced by something better. Where a pick has been dropped because it went out of production or out of stock, the slot is re-sourced rather than left pointing at a listing you cannot buy.

3. How third-party testing is treated

Where somebody has genuinely tested something, we cite them by name and date and link to the work. The most substantial physical testing in this category — inflation timing, wind and water spray on Halloween inflatables — was published by Reviewed in October 2023, and we reference it as theirs, with the date shown, because a three-season-old test is still the best evidence available and you should know how old it is.

4. Samples from brands

Brands sometimes send us products to test. We keep them, we disclose them on the page, and they get the same testing and verdict as anything we buy.

A sample is scored against the same published criteria as everything else in its category, and it can finish anywhere — including off the page. Sending something does not guarantee coverage or a positive verdict, there are no paid placements and no paid reviews, and the brand has no sight of the write-up before it goes live. Where a pick was sent to us, the page says so at the top and names the brand. Samples are not returned. Brands can read the whole process on the For Brands page.

5. How prices are handled

Prices render only from a live data layer with a date attached. When no live price is available, the page says “check price” rather than showing a number that may be months out of date.

Every price on this site is pulled from the retailer’s own live product data, is stamped with the date it was read, and is dropped back to “check price” if that reading goes stale. That way the figure you budget against is the figure on the listing when you click through.

6. How content is updated

Halloween content goes stale in a very specific way — half the pages ranking in this category are a season or more out of date, some with the wrong year still in the headline. Our cadence:

  • June to July: research current-season models across every category.
  • July: every roundup refreshed, and every outbound product link verified to still resolve to something actually sold. A buy link to a discontinued product is the worst trust failure an affiliate site can have.
  • August: everything live and submitted for indexing before demand ramps.
  • September to October: monitor and fix only.
  • January: full audit — dead links retired, discontinued products removed.

Date honesty: a “last updated” date reflects a real content change, and our sitemap reports each page’s own content date, so a fresh date on a page means fresh research behind it.

7. How to report an error

Email contact@hauntandhedge.com or use the contact form. If you are right, we will correct the page and re-date it. If a correction changes a recommendation, we will say so on the page rather than quietly swapping it.

8. Affiliate relationships

Haunt & Hedge earns commission from qualifying purchases made through links on this site, at no extra cost to you. Commission rates do not decide rankings. Every pick links to a listing we checked ourselves, and where a product we had rated is no longer sold we replace it with one that is and rewrite the entry from the new listing, rather than leaving a dead link in a ranking.

Every page carrying an affiliate link declares it above the first link, not only in the footer. The full statement is on the affiliate disclosure page.

9. Who writes this

Mike M. — the hands-on owner behind Iron Mako Media. One author, writing every page on the site. More on the about page.